Entertainment

Miss Zimbabwe vs. Miss Matofotofo vs. Miss Curvy: The Frontier of Beauty

Miss Zimbabwe

Bongani Dlakama, Miss Zimbabwe 2012

When former Miss Zimbabwe Brita Masalethulini emerged winner of the Miss Malaika beauty pageant, Zimbabweans were elated. She instantly became a household name because she was the winner of Africa’s most prestigious beauty contest. My interest peaked too and I began to follow every Miss Malaika edition. Unfortunately, Zimbabwe never won again. My interest in the competition therefore slowly died down. That is until something unusual began to happen. A new kind of beauty pageant burst onto the Zimbabwean social scene – Miss Matofotofo. Not long afterwards, another novel one began making waves in the country. This one was called “Miss Curvy”. It was then clear to me that a beauty pageant war was in full swing in Zimbabwe.

I never thought too deeply about Miss Malaika, or Miss Zimbabwe, or Miss Tourism Zimbabwe. It just seemed  like several girls walked onto stage, paraded themselves and answered test questions before the judges selected a winner. The girls competed in different categories, usually casual wear, evening wear and swim wear. In Zimbabwe, I don’t remember seeing the swim wear category too many times, but it did become more prominent over time. We even began to see more of it in magazines. Growing up, I was personally uncomfortable with it. Many people also grew uncomfortable with the pageants, but for very different reasons.

Miss Matofotofo was launched in 2005 in Zimbabwe. Commentators say “Matofotofo”  means “big and fluffy.” (the root of the word itself means soft, not firm, or squishy). The name was later changed to Miss True African Queen (Miss TAQ), after “matofotofo” proved to be somewhat derogatory to larger women. The Matofotofo project began as a reactionary movement to conventional beauty pageants, where ideal candidates were usually thin and tall. The Miss TAQ women wanted to be appreciated with their bigger bodies. Even more than that, they began to argue that their bodies were truer representations of African beauty. The idea soon caught on and spread to other regional countries, becoming especially popular in Malawi. Many African women were excited about this new development. But some were still dissatisfied.

Constance Kachoka, Miss “Matofotofo” Malawi 2012

Miss Curvy was therefore launched in 2011 in Zimbabwe. The founder, Mercy Mushaninga, said about the new pageant:

“Miss Curvy does not have strict guiding principles. Anyone who has curves and keeps a flat tummy is eligible depending on the age group that we will prescribe for the pageant. One does not have to have a serious modeling background to participate because we just look for physical beauty with emphasis on the curves.”

While Miss Curvy also does not have the thin-tall requirement, it does require “curves.” As such, it can be viewed as somewhat of a hybrid between Miss True African Queen and Miss Zimbabwe.

Miss Curvy Zimbabwe 2012 Contestant

A Miss Curvy Zimbabwe 2012 Contestant

There are interesting similarities in all three pageants. They all have physical appearance standards. Tall and thin for Miss Zimbabwe, curvy for Miss Curvy Zimbabwe and “over size 40” for Miss TAQ (at least for some past editions). Zimbabwe has women for all categories. Some do qualify for both Miss Curvy and Miss True African Queen, but it is very unlikely that anyone from these two will qualify for Miss Zimbabwe. In fact, many contestants in the two pageants claim that they always wanted to compete, but couldn’t make it into Miss Zimbabwe because of body size/shape.

Historically, Miss Zimbabwe has been more prestigious and exclusive. It is the pageant that has stronger ties with the Tourism Ministry of Zimbabwe. It has therefore been a “face of Zimbabwe” for the international scene, adhering to the international standard of beauty that also requires tall and thin. Potential models have therefore been more likely to change their weight for Miss Zimbabwe. Brita Masalethulini, who has spoken of her weight gain since her Miss Zimbabwe (1999) and Miss Malaika (2001) triumphs, recognizes this issue, and has said:

“There is different understanding attached to the industry. Young ladies should not be starving themselves. They should be disciplined and taking good care of themselves. At the moment the world needs healthy models that can be good role models.”

Founders of Miss Curvy and Miss TAQ – who are both women – took the critique a step further. They founded their pageants as push backs against Miss Zimbabwe standards and as havens for the women who had been excluded for their size.

However, the two still have their own physical requirements. Bigger women for one and more curvaceous women for the other. It is likely that many women who qualify for Miss Zimbabwe will not qualify for Miss Curvy or Miss TAQ. And if they do, they might be disappointed to learn that Miss Curvy and Miss TAQ do not have a bikini category. (Interestingly, Miss World 2013 will not have this category also, in respect of the culture of the host country – Indonesia).

Despite the differences, all three pageants agree on one thing: that beauty is more than physical. They all understand this non-physical aspect of beauty differently. Some of them test for intelligence, some for social awareness, some for character and a host of other things. This is all in recognition of the assertion that a true Zimbabwean beauty should also be beautiful inside – in the heart/brain. Still, there is no agreement on how a true, beautiful Zimbabwean woman should look. Or if there is a single standard anyway.

The conversation continues. Miss Zimbabwe demands, among other things, tall and skinny. Miss Curvy demands curves and flat tummies. Miss TAQ is looking for bigger women. Each draws its own support, and each is an audible voice in the Zimbabwean discourse on beauty. All three are very much alive. Brita (Miss Zimbabwe and Miss Malaika) went to the US in 2002 to promote the Miss Malaika pageant, and Miss Zimbabwe continues to represent the country at Miss World competitions. Miss TAQ has gone regional and has become especially popular in Malawi. Miss Curvy is rebranding to “Diamond Queen of Africa,” and holds Africa’s inaugural “Miss Curvy” in Harare, Zimbabwe next week. Zimbabwe is indeed a frontier of beauty (pageants).

What do you think of these pageants?  Should we have them all? Should we have them at all?

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Miss Zimbabwe vs. Miss Matofotofo vs. Miss Curvy: The Frontier of Beauty

  1. I am Ms American Beauties Plus National Queen. Why are women with tummies are big stomaches not included? That is discrimination are we not past that with all we’ve been through?

    Like

  2. Your vision is good and I pray and hope that the girls who participate in this peagents enter in for the propagation of this vision not for selfish reasons. You are a true model

    Like

  3. Thank you for the story…. As the organiser of The Diamond Queen of Africa aka “Miss Curvy” I started this pageant in 2011 after the 70km walk from Harare to Marondera launch of a project called “Models Against Hunger in Africa (MAHA)”. MAHA is a charity project that seeks to look back at our traditional ways of looking after orphans in the community. It is not common in our culture to send an orphan to a home when he/she has relatives in the community, grandparents choose to share the little that they have with the orphan than to take the child to an orphanage home. So the idea of Miss Curvy came as a way of choosing an Ambassador of Orphans in the communities, since most organisations concentrate on donating to orphanage homes neglecting the orphans in the community. The reason of choosing a curvy model was not about physical beauty “NO” because this is not a Beauty Pageant it is a “Charity Pageant”, and looking for a Curvy model was also a way empowering the girl child with duties to do in their communities. The change of name from Miss Curvy to “The Diamond Queen” came as way of reminding people that this pageant is not all about Curves, Curves and a model with huge Curves but that of a precious kind of woman who has the heart of giving back to the community…. I would also want to take this opportunity to thank everyone who is supporting the cause and we have managed to make a difference to a few kids in the community and our greatest wish is to see every orphan in the community benefit from our project.

    Like

    • Wow thank you for taking the time to give us all the information. I personally laud you for the incredible work you are doing for orphans, and I especially admire the idea behind it. I think it’s the part of the message that I missed, probably together with a lot of other people. It would be great to get to learn about the project as a whole, not just the pageant part. In fact, would you point me to resources that I can use to write a fuller piece on the project? Better yet, would you be so kind as to allow me an interview, so I can learn more about you great project. Thank you again!

      Like

  4. Thanks for your comment, Brittany. Yes, exclusivity remains. It would be interesting if somebody hosted a pageant with no physical requirements. I’m not sure if such a pageant would embrace everyone equally though.

    Like

  5. This article was very informative and inspired many thoughts. I respect and appreciate the pageant creators for recognizing and celebrating “alternative” or “non-mainstream” representations of beauty. The underlying problem of exclusion, however, still remains. It is as if the celebration of a particular body type inevitably suggest the criticism of a different body type; ___ group can’t embrace their ___ness without implicitly insulting/critiquing the “other’ group. Furthermore, what about the women who don’t fit the tall/skinny mold, or the big or the curvy? Will they get their own alternative pageant?

    Like

What do you think? Share your views!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s